Browsing by Author "Mustafa, Shams"

Now showing 1 - 8 of 8

Becon of hope: an impact assessment study of BRAC rural development programme (executive summary and conclusion)
(BRAC, 1996-02) Mustafa, Shams; Ara, Ishrat; Banu, Dilruba; Hussain, Altaf; Kabir, Azmal; Mohsin, Md.; Yousuf, Abu; Jahan, Sarwar
Impact assessment study of BRAC's Rural Development Programme: final report (unedited draft for comments)
(© BRAC, 1995-08) Mustafa, Shams; Ara, Ishrat; Banu, Dilruba; Hossain, Altaf; Kabir, Ajmal; Mohsin, Mohammad; Yusuf, Abu
Impact of Oxbow Lakes Project II on participant households
(BRAC, 1997-04) Ahmed, Dilruba; Hossain, Altaf; Mustafa, Shams
The Oxbow Lakes Small Scale Fishermen Development Project Phase II (OLP-11) is being financed jointly by International Fund for Agricultural Development (IF AD), Danish International Development Assistance (DANIDA), World Food Programme (WFP), Government of Bangladesh (GoB) and implemented jointly by Project Implementation Unit (PIU) of GoB, Directorate of Fisheries (DoF), DANIDA and BRAC since June 1991. BRAC is entrusted with organizing the fishermen at the grassroots level, capacity development of the fishermen through management and skill training, credit support, and raising of productivity through extension of technical services to improve the condition of the rural poor fishermen in particular, and to eradicate rural poverty, in general This study focuses on the impact of the Second Oxbow Lake Project (OLP II) on participant fishermen households. The objective of the study is to provide the analysis of the changes in the material well-being of the participant households and to discuss the changes in the lives of the non-participants of the oxbow lake catchment areas as a result of OLP II intervention The study gathered data through survey in 1993 and resurvey in 1995 from 1189 participant and non-participant households of 21 oxbow lake catchment areas. The households were randomly selected for conducting survey. Both participants and non-participants are the members of BRAC's Rural Development Programme (RDP). To find out the displaced fishermen household due to the OLP II intervention and to know their economic condition the study also included case study in 3 oxbow lake catchment areas. Positive changes have taken place in the oxbow lake catchment areas as a result of the fishermen's participation in the OLP !i. These changes have been categorized into two broad areas, i.e., material well-being of the participant households as well as the indirect impact of the OLP on the inhabitants of the oxbow lake catchment areas and displacement caused by the project. According to the findings the shelter environment in terms of electricity facility and sanitation of the participant households has improved compared to that of the non-participant households.
Impact of the Oxbowlakes project on participant households (preliminary report)
(BRAC, 1995-09) Mustafa, Shams; Hossain, Altaf; Amin, Nurul; Mallick, A.H.; Banu, Dilruba; Kabir, Azmal
Main Findings reports of the RDP impact assessment study
(BRAC, 1995-02) Mustafa, Shams; Ara, lshrat; Moshin, M.; Banu, Dilruba; Kabir, Azmal; Rural development projects--Bangladesh.
Introduction The 1993-94 Impact Assessment Study (lAS) of the Rural Development Programme (RDP) has been carried out by BRAC's Research and Evaluation Division, with consultancy assistance from the Centre for Development Studies, Swansea. RDP's Impact on the Material Well-Being of Members Overall, the IAS results indicate a consistent movement along the path to greater wealth and expenditure, according to loan size and membership age. While there are undoubtedly other non-RDP factors which influence the real level of wealth of different households, the main finding of the analysis is that when RDP households receive substantial amounts of credit over a long membership period significant changes become measurable. In addition, the results show that RDP is impacting on less well off (low endowment) households to a comparatively greater degree than better off households; and furthermore they imply that the focus on (generally poorer) female members is more effective in bringing benefits to BRAC's target group than would be the case with a higher proportion of male membership. RDP's Impact on Vulnerability and Coping Capacity Changes in the nature of household assets, with increases in the monetary value of productive (revenue earning) fixed and working capital, along with investment in housing structures, suggest both greater economic security and an improved standard of living for "older" members of RDP. Such enhanced security is confirmed most clearly by the reduced seasonal fluctuations in income, expenditure, food consumption and stocks for those members who joined RDP more than two and a half years ago, and have received over Tk 7,500 of cumulative RDP loans. These findings clearly indicate that seasonal vulnerability of such households has decreased markedly. In addition, the evidence concerning enhanced coping capacity is generally positive. There is a trend to "withdraw" from the informal credit market, the average amount • of credit taken by "older" members declines, and the use of both RDP and informal• loans for consumption or hardship purposes decreases with length of membership, just as households experience improvements in their material well-being and ability to weather seasonal lean and peak periods. Changes in Women's Lives While dramatic changes are not evident, there are some (more gradual) changes which BRAC has brought about in female members' lives. After receiving loans women's status has increased within the household. Some have experienced greater mobility. Many of the members involved in BRAC "sectoral" programmes have gained more control over their income, and the ability to decide about how (and how much) to • save and spend on themselves and on their children. However, from the experience of the case studies the majority of rural house-bound women have few opportunities to use loans by themselves without some assistance of male family members. Unless BRAC provides women with necessary support services close to the bari, they have few alternatives other than to hand over part or all of their loans to male kin, which .often means they cannot exercise full control over their loans and credit based resources. The length of involvement with BRAC appears to have little bearing on the degree of change that women experienced. It may be argued that RDP field staff can have little influence on what goes on within a household. Institution Building It is acknowledged that institution building is a lengthy and complex process. The main findings of the case studies are not very encouraging. High rates of turnover, confusion and dissatisfaction about savings and GTF rules and procedures, and the strong emphasis on credit operations and discipline has limited the extent to which members value their VOs as potentially autonomous support groups. In general, discipline and enthusiasm is more evident in the newer and female VOs. This is due primarily to the fact that such discipline is seen as a pre-condition for applying for credit. Over time, such discipline declines, ideal procedures become less common, and meeting attendance becomes more erratic. VOs rarely undertake additional activities in a collective manner, or independent from BRAC's initiative, suggesting that they are not progressing to semi-autonomous institutions. Moreover, the frequent rule changes, combined with the frequent transfer of staff, have created a degree of uncertainty for members. In many VOs, leadership has developed as an instrument through which field staff maintain repayment discipline. The operation of the peer group joint liability mechanism is commonly at the level of the whole VO rather than at the level of small 5-6 member groups (these rarely exist in older VOs). It is therefore apparent that VOs are primarily valued by members, and operate as, credit groups. In the few cases in which VOs have acted as a collectivity in the past, their success appears to have been connected to high levels of staff motivation. One VO which had been established during the Outreach period - when staff interaction was more intensive - reported a history of attempting collective activities. These have ceased, and many members have left, during more recent years under RDP. The Non-Formal Primary Education Programme After a second or third cycle of an NFPE school the degree of VO involvement (measured by the number and proportion of member-children attending) tends to decline. However, VOs' retain a pride in, and link with school affairs, which implies that they remain a key benefit for VOs. The schools provide a highly valued service to poorer families; perceptions of school quality are overwhelmingly positive. Except for the issue of religious curriculum content, few criticisms were voiced during group interviews. Examples of conflict are rare. The key example of this is the need to ensure priority (or "first choice") to poorer households during school enrolment - which can be done by carefully organised and phased child selection. However, the case studies also show that NFPE schools are not exclusively "poor peoples' " schools, but tend to include children from all wealth classes. This, in effect, is a result of the schools' perceived qualities - they are attractive to those outside of BRAC's target group.
Planning and project appraisal: a brief on the Deep Tube Well (DTW) irrigation programme of BRAC
(BRAC, 1989-07) Mustafa, Shams; Rahman, Sanzidur; Irrigation--Bangladesh.
Restoring sights: a story of six eye care projects in Bangladesh
(© BRAC, 1986-11-15) Chowdhury, A. Muahtaque R.; Mustafa, Shams